Question
更新於
2021年7月22日
- 日語
-
英語 (美國)
有關 英語 (美國) 的問題
I have a sensitive question.
It is about the murder of George Floyd.
I'm using a translator, so I'm sorry if I'm rude.
My impression is that of course cops are bad guys, but George Floyd did bad things too.
He was a repeat offender, and the autopsy showed that the cause of death was drugs, not asphyxiation.
In my country, we do not discriminate on the basis of skin color.
It doesn't matter if the person who committed the crime is black, white, Asian, or whoever.
So I was surprised to hear that they built a statue to honor him like a hero.
It's sad when people die.
But I don't think he is a hero.
There are many other black heroes.
There are also many respectable people who are doing their best for the world.
↓
I have a sensitive question.
It is about the murder of George Floyd.
I'm using a translator, so I'm sorry if I'm rude.
My impression is that of course cops are bad guys, but George Floyd did bad things too.
He was a repeat offender, and the autopsy showed that the cause of death was drugs, not asphyxiation.
In my country, we do not discriminate on the basis of skin color.
It doesn't matter if the person who committed the crime is black, white, Asian, or whoever.
So I was surprised to hear that they built a statue to honor him like a hero.
It's sad when people die.
But I don't think he is a hero.
There are many other black heroes.
There are also many respectable people who are doing their best for the world.
↓
It is about the murder of George Floyd.
I'm using a translator, so I'm sorry if I'm rude.
My impression is that of course cops are bad guys, but George Floyd did bad things too.
He was a repeat offender, and the autopsy showed that the cause of death was drugs, not asphyxiation.
In my country, we do not discriminate on the basis of skin color.
It doesn't matter if the person who committed the crime is black, white, Asian, or whoever.
So I was surprised to hear that they built a statue to honor him like a hero.
It's sad when people die.
But I don't think he is a hero.
There are many other black heroes.
There are also many respectable people who are doing their best for the world.
↓
答覆
When you "disagree" with an answer
The owner of it will not be notified.
Only the user who asked this question will see who disagreed with this answer.
查看更多留言
- 日語
↓
What I think about this incident is that it is a sad case of bad things happening together.
Again, the cop is of course at fault.
It's also sad that black people are discriminated against and treated badly.
But I can't understand why that makes him a hero, no matter how many times I watch the news.
I was even more surprised when I heard that a huge compensation was paid to his family.
Do most Americans still think of him as a hero?
I only know him from the news, so I would like to know what people living in the US think about him.
What I think about this incident is that it is a sad case of bad things happening together.
Again, the cop is of course at fault.
It's also sad that black people are discriminated against and treated badly.
But I can't understand why that makes him a hero, no matter how many times I watch the news.
I was even more surprised when I heard that a huge compensation was paid to his family.
Do most Americans still think of him as a hero?
I only know him from the news, so I would like to know what people living in the US think about him.
- 英語 (美國)
Omg! This is such a cool question 🤩 Ok! George is seen as a hero because he represents ( represents means being the face or symbol of something) an African American in America. African Americans are black people born in America. Since he is a representation we are not looking at him and his past. We are looking at the community he is part of, the black community. He was a hero because he was an African American that was “sacrificed” to help the world be more aware of what is happening to people of color. In the U.S people that are part of this group are called “the minority”, along with Asians, people that are part of LGBTQ, and any other non-white races. This is because they are the oppressed, they’re voices have to fight to be heard. George Floyd’s death was a turning point in U.S history. It was a fight that led to death and change. And you DID NOT sound rude at all.
- 日語
- 英語 (美國)
I’m going to chime in because I have a completely different perspective. First, the medical examiner determined that heart disease and drug use CONTRIBUTED to his death, but were not the primary cause. Had the police officer not choked him to death, George Floyd would still be alive.
That said, I don’t think he is a hero, nor do a lot of people. However, the fact of the matter is that no matter what you’ve done, police officers aren’t supposed to kill you. George Floyd doing bad things in the past or even when he got arrested/murdered is completely beside the point. And him being murdered is why his family received compensation. It’s also why what happened to him has received a lot of news coverage and attention. It’s not to portray him as a hero, but to bring awareness to the very real and life-threatening dangers Black people face every day.
Also, I have to say that I disagree about him being a “sacrifice”. In my opinion, that term is very dehumanizing and only leads to the issue being sugarcoated. And while change may have resulted from his murder and the subsequent protests, I don’t think it was a turning point. Police took the lives of thousands of Black people before George Floyd and are still doing it now.
Lastly, @na20na there is discrimination everywhere. And although you may not see it, it does exist. I think you should do more research and speak to more people of color/people who do not look like you to become more informed on George Floyd and the topic of racism/discrimination in general.
高評價回答者
[通知]Hi! 正在學習外文的你
你知道如何提升自己的外語能力嗎❓你要做的就是讓母語者來訂正你的寫作！
使用HiNative，免費讓母語者來幫你訂正文章✍️✨
使用HiNative，免費讓母語者來幫你訂正文章✍️✨
註冊
相關提問
-
Could anyone please explain about this part of the paragraph.
"others were pretty wounding, espe...
回答It means that some racial slurs hurt him on a deeper level than than other racial slurs that were being said on the internet, because some w...
-
Just so you know, the ENTIRE WORLD is with George Floyd.
Life in prison for all four of these cr...
回答It should be "murderers."
-
What does "landed" of "landed one of the punches" mean?
Context>>>>>>>>>>>>
It is unclear w...
回答that means he was swinging at the perpetrator and nobody knows if he landed a punch if he actually made contact with his fist to the other pe...
-
It's very serious problems.
Japanese had attacked people include civil people ,I don't know the d...
回答I think every country has made some sort of hard decision in the past, like whether or not to attack. Both America and Japan attacked each o...
-
In the last sentence of the following paragraph, what does the writer want to say?
Does the wri...
回答The author is trying to draw attention to the fact that Darnella Frazier was harassed for not "doing more" when George Floyd was being killed...
-
It would be appreciated if you could correct sentences below.
A grudging ex-employer (and also...
回答@Akira1991 You can! I assumed the security guard may have mistaken the baby for a disguised bomb.
-
hi i am a french student can you correct the mistakes in the text that i write:
Dear classmates...
回答hey these are some corrections: 1. on 25th of may 2020 / on may 25th 2020 2. minneapolis 3. derek chauvin 4. knelt on 5. even if floyd was al...
-
🔳I was under the impression that the famous actor was very disciplined when I saw some videos on ...
回答@leitesertes It sounds formal in terms of vocabulary but is right
-
Here is a comment on the resent verdict on derek chauvin horrible crime..
The comment says well ...
回答@Michael___ Here is a comment on the recent verdict of Derek Chauvin’s horrible crime. The comment says it all well. And honestly, I wish t...
-
Opinions in Japan and in the U.S. are divided about Will Smith slapped.
It seems there are many p...
回答@tpmgwgmg Opinions in Japan and the U.S. are divided about Will Smith's slap. It seems there are many people who defend him in Japan. We k...
相同關鍵字的提問
- Which is more natural? Can I ask a question? Or can I ask you a question?
- I have a little question about linguistic. That is what is Xbar theory? What functions does it h...
- I have a question regarding the following sentence. "I aimed my remarks at Susan, but she did...
矚目的提問
- Всем привет, посоветуйте с чего лучше начать изучение английского, так как простые фразы я понима...
- what is correct? Where are you study? Or Where do you study? Thank you.
- Hello everyone! I hope you all are doing good. Please Iet me know if l made l mistake here or pl...
- 日本語を人に教えてあげるときに 丁寧に話す時 XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX 日常会話で話す時 XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX と書きたいです。 「丁寧に話す時」...
- What does "bombaclat" mean? I see this word on twitter a lot, but still have no idea.
最新問題(HOT)
- 请问掺和拌有什么区别?欢迎举例，谢谢
- 標題這樣子寫看得懂嗎？「吸引日本人台灣魅力是!?」
- 【「去」跟「來」】 下面兩句意思差不多嗎？ （最近講述南韓新興宗教的紀錄片播出後掀起對所謂「邪教」的新一波討論。 有些觀眾可能會納悶） a）像這類型的團體為什麼得以存活下去？ ...
- 我們外國人學習中文時容易把第一聲與第四聲搞混，請問這個錯誤很嚴重嗎？如果念錯的話會不會讓你們聽不懂呢？有什麼辦法可以改進這個錯誤嗎？謝謝
- 我的錢嘛，讓我想要怎麼用就怎麼用嘛 這句很自然嗎？
最新問題
- 请问掺和拌有什么区别?欢迎举例，谢谢
- 各位覺得 像HiNative這種語言學習的問答網站 在未來會不會被Chatgpt或類似的人工智能取代? 我發現大部分的問題AI都能回答 :{
- 跟「魅力」一樣的意思的單字還有什麼？
- 日本語で翻訳してください 我们不會稱讚日本人他的日文真好 也不會跟英國人説他们英文真好
- 標題這樣子寫看得懂嗎？「吸引日本人台灣魅力是!?」
上一個問題/下一個問題
這是什麽符號？
這個標誌代表你有興趣的語言的程度到哪裡，幫助回答者提供和程度相對應的回答。
-
初級
難以理解使用非母語語言的回答
-
初中級
能夠提出簡單的問題，也可以理解簡單的回答。
-
中級
能夠提出一般程度的問題，也能夠理解大部分的答案。
-
上級
能夠完整理解問題與回答。
註冊高級用戶，便可播放其他用戶問題下語音/影片的答案。
什麼是禮物?
比起按讚跟貼圖更能表達你的感謝之情
贈送禮物將會讓你更容易收到答案！
您在送某人禮物後所發布的問題，該問題將在顯示對方時間軸上顯眼的位子。
對查詢感到厭倦了嗎？HiNative可以幫你找到想要的答案。
